Just wanted to mention here that a NC clause would mean that it’s not open source anymore.
I created a Printables account for AMYBO and uploaded both @RobJ 's and @SandrineH 's designs. I licensed them both as CC-BY as they’re both remixes of CC-BY designs. Please let me know if there’s anything I should change or add!
I also created an AMYBO.org Printables group that anyone can join.
Regarding how AMYBO would license any strains that are developed and submitted for regulatory approval, I’d like to suggest the BiOS license.
I came across the wikipedia page for PatentLeft this morning, which is analogous to copyleft (like GPL) and used by BiOS (Biological Innovation for Open Society):
TransBacter is available to all non-profit researchers and institutes upon signing a BiOS MTA. For-profit companies are asked to sign a BiOS license and to make a contribution to Cambia which is calculated on the company’s financial means.
More details here: BiOS Agreements FAQs – Cambia
This is brilliant - thanks Gerrit - it’s great to see there’s a precedent that we can quote. I’ve checked out their docs and registration and Cambia seem solid.
Claude asked me to confirm, where we stand on licensing - as we’re planning on producing some interactive videos, and should really give the electroPioreactor repo a LICENCE.md. While YouTube is a no-brainer if you want videos out there for discovery, it’s not the lowest carbon option, Claude thinks CC-BY-SA 4.0 licensing would let us use Wikimedia commons to host videos.
So to summarise, unless otherwise specified, AMYBO IP is licensed as:
- 3D models, photos, images (including CAD renders), video (outside YouTube): CC-BY-SA 4.0
- Other Hardware: CERN-OHL-S-2.0
- Pioreactor Plugins MIT
- Other Software: AGPL-3.0
- Text and data: CC-BY-4.0
- Genetic Material: TBA
Entities requiring more permissive licensing can do so by:
- Entering a contract to pay reasonable royalties to AMYBO, or
- Providing regular updates to AMYBO on how people are benefiting from the IP if such IP is used exclusively in LDCs
Unless anyone objects by 11 September, I will add LICENCE.md files to the electroPioreactor repository on this basis.
I think CC-BY-SA 4.0 is great for videos. I wasn’t aware that YouTube doesn’t allow for that license.
Have you considered PeerTube? That integrates well with the fediverse, and due to the P2P nature of the video delivery mechanism I imagine it would have a lower carbon impact than even Wikimedia Commons. The PeerTube app even lets you cast to your TV with Chromecast nowadays - it’s come along quite a bit since I last used it.